Millicent A. Ndiya disowns Ringa Girls audit report, blames predecessor Jane Murigi for corruption and financial mismanagement


All is not well at Ringa Girls High School in Homa Bay County following a report by the Auditor-General regarding Ringa Girls' High School for the fiscal year ending 30 June 2025.

The report has revealed financial irregularities, corruption, mismanagement of school finances, and the embezzlement of school funds. The current principal, Millicent A. Ndiya, who signed the report on 25 February 2026, has distanced herself from the allegations, asserting that the report pertains to the period when Jane M. Murigi was in charge since 2022. According to Ndiya, she inherited a financially troubled school from Murigi, who she claims had mismanaged the school's finances, leaving her with substantial unpaid bills as suppliers and contractors had not been compensated despite the Board of Management (BoG) approving payments. Ndiya alleges that her predecessor, Murigi, only paid suppliers and contractors who were willing to provide kickbacks. She further indicates that BoG teachers were inadequately compensated and were owed salary arrears, which she has now settled. Ndiya contends that the report solely reflects Murigi’s tenure and that she bears no responsibility for the reported misconduct, mismanagement, and looting, all of which occurred during Murigi’s administration. Madam Ndiya asserts that her predecessor, Murigi, operated the school with an iron fist, employing intimidation, threats, and coercion against those with differing opinions. She claims to have transformed the school's operations into a more professional environment, in stark contrast to Murigi's leadership.


AUDITOR GENERAL REPORT (UNEDITED)

Unsupported School Fund lncome - Parents' Contributions 

The statement of financial performance on the financial statements, reflects school fund income - parents' contributions amount of Kshs.39,893,011. However, no schedules disclosing the student names, amounts and time when the fees were paid were produced to support the balance. ln the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of the School fund income parents' contributions of Kshs. 39,893,011 could not be confirmed.


Variance Between the Financial Statements and Ledgers 

The statement of financial performance, and as disclosed in Note 4 to the financial statements, reflects school fund income - parents contributions amount of Kshs.39,893,011 which includes fee on boarding of equipment and stores Kshs.29,658,485. 

However, the supporting ledger reflects a corresponding amount of Kshs.28,883,512, resulting to unexplained variance of Kshs.774,973. 

The statement of financial performance, and as disclosed in Note 8 to the financial statements, reflects infrastructure expenditure amount of Kshs.3,987,420 in respect of construction of classrooms. 

However, the supporting ledger shows a corresponding amount of Kshs.4,468,900, resulting to unexplained variance of Kshs.481,480. ln the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of the financial statements could not be confirmed. 


Unsupported Accounts Payable 

The statement of assets and liabilities reflects accounts payable balance of Kshs.143,340 as disclosed in Note 14 to the financial statements, which includes prepaid fees of 86,886. However, the list of students who had prepaid fees was not provided for audit review. 

ln the circumstances, the accuracy, classification, and completeness of the account payables balance of Kshs.143,340 could not be confirmed. 


Late Submission of Financial Statements 

The financial statements for Ringa Girls' High School for the year ended 30 June, 2025 were submitted to the Office of the Auditor-General for audit on 4 March 2026. This was contrary to Paragraph 1.8 of the National Treasury and Economic Planning circular Ref: No:AG.3/88 Vol.Vll (41) dated 4 December,2024 which required all public sector entities for County and National Government to prepare and submit annual financial statements by 31 August,2025. ln the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.


Failure to lmplement an lmprest Management System 

Review of the operations and financial transactions of Ringa Girls High School revealed that the School did not issue imprest warrants or record in the imprest register and cash advances made to various staff to carry out School's activities during the year under review. 

This was contrary to Regulation 93(4)(b)(c) of the Public Finance Management (National Government) Regulations 2015 that provides that before issuing temporary imprests under paragraph (2), the Accounting Officer shall ensure that the applicant has no outstanding imprests; and the applicant has been recorded in the imprest register including the amount applied for. 

ln the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law


Lack of an Approved Risk Management Policy 

During the year under review, the School did not have an approved risk management policy to provide a framework for the management of risk and to increase overall awareness of risk throughout the institution. 

ln the absence of an approved risk management policy, the School has been left exposed as they cannot mitigate potential risks that may arise. ln the circumstances, the effectiveness of the schools' risk identification and mitigation procedures could not be confirmed. 


Weak lnternal Control Environment 

Ringa Girls High School operates a manual system of revenue collection despite having a student population of eight hundred and seventy-eight (878) and collecting Kshs.53,932,939, in revenue. Schoolfees receipts are issued manually by a single officer who is also expected to update the fees register and keep a record of all the unpaid fees. 

ln addition, the lnstitution does not have a documented Code of Conduct for employees, a Human Resource Policy and Procedures Manual, or an appropriate governance framework, including an approved and up{o-date organizational structure. Furthermore, there is no Disaster Recovery Plan in place. 

Further, the school has not developed and implemented documented policies and procedures to guide key financial processes and controls relating to: revenue collection and management, expenditure processing and authorization, personnel expenditure, inventory management, management of liabilities. 

ln the circumstances, the effectiveness of the Schools' internal controls could not be confirmed.


Non-Functional Audit Committee 

Key School lnformation and Management section of the financial statements indicates the School has an Audit Committee which held one (1) meeting. 

However, no minutes of the meeting were provided to demonstrate that the committee performs oversight functions over the school's financral records, internal controls, risk management, implementation of internal and external audit recommendations and overall operational activities. 

ln the circumstances, the effectiveness of the audit committee in providing oversight over the School's affairs could not be confirmed. 


Weaknesses in the Management of Inventories and Stores 

The statement of financial performance reflects boarding and school fund expenses amounting to Kshs.33,862,284 as disclosed in Note 9 to the financial statements. 

lncluded in this balance is an amount of Kshs.4,925,803 spent on purchasing food stuffs, construction materials and stationery which were never taken on charge with a counter receipt voucher and therefore not entered in the store's ledger cards. 

ln addition, it was noted that no requisition forms were raised or Local Purchase Orders issued. Consequently, the accountability for goods procured and paid for could not be confirmed.

ln the circumstances, the effectiveness of the internal controls on inventories and stores could not be confirmed.


Long Outstanding Receivables 

The statement of assets and liabilities reflects accounts receivable balance of Kshs.1 ,361,423 which, as disclosed in Note 13 to the financialstatements, includes fees arrears balance of Kshs.1,304,915. 

lncluded in this balance is fees arrears balance of Kshs.529,942 which had been outstanding for more than one (1) year. However, there was no detailed age analysis and policy on the impairment of long outstanding fees arrears casting doubt on full recoverability of the accounts receivables balance. 

ln the circumstances, the existence of effective mechanisms for fees arrears management could not be confirmed.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Pressure Mounts on TSC as Parents, Stakeholders Seek Transfer of Wiobiero Principal Samuel Abuoro as Grade 10 students complain of sexual harassment

Stakeholders Reject Madam Ann Mwangangi as New Principal at Makueni Girls As Makueni Community Demands Local Principal Appointment