Hillary Kiriswo accused of enlisting police to intimidate reporters over a Bortolimo Boys High School report
The Employment and Labour Relations Court Nakuru has ORDERED the Board of Management of BORTOLIMO BOYS HIGH SCHOOL to promptly enter into a recognition agreement with the KENYA UNION OF DOMESTIC, HOTELS, EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS AND HOSPITAL WORKERS.Until the issuance of this order, the employees had been prohibited from joining the union, as determined by the Employment and Labour Relations Court in a ruling delivered in Nakuru on the 12th of June, 2026, by ANNA NGIBUINI MWAURE. Our efforts to contact the school principal, who also serves as the secretary to the Board of Management, Hillary Kiriswo, were met with intimidating phone calls from police officers (names withheld) due to the ongoing investigation.
THE AUTHENTICATED COPY OF THE JUDGEMENT (UNEDITAED)
REPUBLIC
OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAKURU
ELRC CAUSE NO. E044 OF 2025
(Before Hon. Lady Justice Anna Ngibuini Mwaure)
KENYA UNION OF DOMESTIC, HOTELS,
EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS AND
HOSPITAL WORKERS...............................................
CLAIMANT
VERSUS
BOM BORTOLIMO BOYS
HIGH SCHOOL............................................
.....RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
Introduction
1. The Claimant instituted this suit via Memorandum of Claim dated 7th January
2025, seeking the following reliefs that:
1.The Honourable court do compel the Respondent to sign the forwarded
Recognition Agreement to allow for negotiations of a Collective Bargaining
Agreement pursuant to section 54 of the Labour Relations Act 2007.
2.The cost of
this suit be awarded to the Claimant.
3.Any other relief the court deems fit.
Claimant’s
case
2. The
Claimant avers its mandate to represent non-teaching staff in educational
institutions and on 10th February 2022, it recruited 19 out of 27 workers at
Bartolimo Boys High School, surpassing the statutory 50+1 threshold under
section 54(1) of the Labour Relations Act, 2007.
3. The Claimant avers that the members signed into the union through check-off
system No. 002172, and authority to deduct and remit union dues was forwarded
to the Respondent on 18th February 2022 pursuant to Kenya Gazette Supplement
No. 135, Legal Notice No. 195 of 1st November 2018, and sections 48 to 50 of
the Labour Relations Act.
4. Despite this, the Claimant avers that the Respondent ignored repeated requests
to deliberate and sign the recognition agreement, including letters dated 27th May,
14th June, 24th August 2022, and reminders on 10th February and 15th May 2023.
5. After warning that failure to respond would lead to escalation, the Claimant
avers that it reported a trade dispute to the Ministry of Labour on 30th August
2024 under section 62(1) of the Labour Relations Act.
The Ministry appointed Ms. Rebecca Kosgei as aconciliator on 18th September
2024, who convened a meeting on 7th October 2024 at the County Labour
Office, Kabarnet.
6. Following two conciliation sessions, she issued a certificate of unresolved
dispute on 7th November 2024 under Section 69 of the Labour Relations Act,
allowing the matter to proceed to arbitration. This sequence demonstrates the
Claimant’s compliance with statutory procedures and the Respondent’s persistent
refusal to engage.
Respondent’s statement of response
7. The Respondent opposed the memorandum of claim vide a statement of response
dated 11th March 2026.
8. The Respondent, represented by the Attorney General, denies most of the
allegations in the Claimant’s Memorandum of Claim, and the Claimant’s mandate
to represent non-teaching staff.
9. The Respondent avers that Bartolimo Boys High School has 34 workers, of whom
only 16 are members of the Claimant union, which does not constitute a simple
majority necessary for recognition.
10. The Respondent acknowledge that a dispute was reported, the conciliator
conducted an audit, and the conciliator failed to resolve the matter.
Ultimately,
the Respondent pray that the suit be dismissed with costs.
11. Parties were directed to file their respective written submissions.
Claimant’s submissions
12. The Claimant submitted that it recruited a simple majority of the respondent’s
workforce, having enrolled 19 out of 34 employees (56%), later maintaining 16
out of 31 employees after retirements, thereby surpassing the statutory threshold
under section 54(1) of the LabourRelations Act, 2007.
The
conciliator’s certificate confirmed the Respondent’s deliberate refusal to
sign a Recognition Agreement despite compliance by the union. The Claimant
emphasized that section 54(1) to (3) of the Labour Relations Act obligates an
employer to recognize a trade union representing a simple majority and to
conclude a written recognition agreement.
13. The Claimant relied on Abyssinia Iron & Steel Limited v Kenya
Engineering Workers Union [2016] KECA 510 (KLR), where the Court of Appeal held
that recognition requires a simple majority of 51%, and KUDHEIHA v BOM Matuu
Memorial Girls High School [2025] KEELRC 2181, where the court affirmed that
recognition agreements must be signed once the threshold is attained. The Claimant
further invoked the Industrial Relations Charter of 1984, which outlines
employer obligations and provides a draft recognition agreement to guide
negotiations.
14. In conclusion, the Claimant argued that the Respondent’s refusal to sign
the agreement amounts to unfair labour practice contrary to Article 41(2) and
(5) of the Constitution of Kenya, and prays for orders compelling the
Respondent to sign the recognition agreement within 30 days, commence collective
bargaining, and pay costs.
15. At the time of writing this judgment, the Respondent did not file their
written submissions either by presenting a hard copy or by filing in the CTS.
Analysis and determination
16. The court has considered the pleadings together with the submissions on
record. The issue for determination is whether the claim had complied with
Sections 48 and 54 of the Labour Relations Act and so had the Respondent failed
to sign the Recognition Agreement in contravention of the law.
17. Section 48 of the Labour Relations Act defines trade union dues as regular
subscriptions paid by members as a condition of union membership. A union may
request the Minister, in the prescribed form, to issue an order directing an
employer with more than five union members to deduct dues from wages and
remit them into specified accounts. Once such an order is issued, the employer
must begin deductions within thirty days of receiving a signed Form S notice from
employees, and the order takes effect the following month. The Minister may
vary, revoke, or suspend the order upon application by the union.
Employers cannot deduct dues from employees who have resigned in writing, with
such resignation taking effect the following month, and must forward a copy
of the resignation notice to the union. In essence, the law establishes a clear
framework for deduction, remittance, variation, and cessation of union dues,
ensuring both employer compliance and protection of employee rights.
18. Section 54(1) of the Labour Relations Act provides as follows:
“An employer, including an employer in the public sector, shall recognise a trade
union for purposes of collective bargaining if that trade union represents the
simple majority of unionisable employees.”
19. In this instant case, the Claimant union recruited 19 out of 27 employees,
who duly appended their signatures to check-off system No. 002172, thereby satisfying
the statutory threshold of 50+1 as prescribed under section 54(1) of the Labour
Relations Act, 2007. Pursuant thereto, the Claimant forwarded a recognition
agreement to the Respondent, who declined to execute the same.
Consequently, the Claimant reported a trade dispute to the Ministry of Labour,
where a conciliator was appointed and convened meetings in an effort to resolve
the matter. The Respondent, however, failed to cooperate, leading to the issuance
of a certificate of unresolved dispute.
20. The court is of the view that the Claimant has discharged its burden of
proof in accordance with Sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act, which
stipulate that he who alleges must prove. In the instant case, documentary
evidence was
adduced showing the check-off forms authorizing deduction of union dues,
together with correspondence requesting execution of the Recognition Agreement.
The Respondent’s failure to comply prompted the Claimant to report the dispute to
the Ministry of Labour, whereupon a conciliator was appointed. Following
unsuccessful conciliation, a certificate of unresolved dispute was duly issued.
21. The court having analysed the Claimant’s case, the Respondent’s
response and the Claimant’s submissions comes to the inevitable conclusion that
the Claimant has proved a case against the Respondent.
The Respondent is ordered to sign the Recognition Agreement pursuant
to Sections 48 and 54 of the Labour Relations Act 2007.
22. The Claimant will have the costs of the suit.
.
Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nakuru
this 12th Day of June, 2026.
ANNA NGIBUINI MWAURE
JUDGE

Comments
Post a Comment