Audit Exposes Deep Mismanagement at Bavuni Secondary School As Principal Julius Mutahi Accused of Embezzlement and Abuse of Power


HIGHLIGHTS

Severe Financial Irregularities and Leadership Failures Uncovered

Allegations of Corruption, Intimidation, and Breach of Trust Shake School Community

Unaccounted School Funds and Questionable Payments Highlight Governance Concerns

Authoritarian Leadership and Political Interference Undermine School Integrity

Audit Reveals Lack of Transparency in School Operations and Spending

Unverified Expenses and Unsupported Payments Raise Red Flags

Ethnic Staffing Imbalance and Legal Breaches Compound School’s Challenges

Bavuni Secondary School's Principal, Julius Mutahi, is currently facing significant challenges following the auditor general's report, which accuses him of mismanagement, embezzlement, and theft of public funds entrusted to him in his role as principal.

  The alarming findings released by the auditor general for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2025, have exposed severe misconduct during his administration. Colleagues at Bavuni High School describe his leadership style as characterized by authoritarianism, intimidation, coercion, threats, and arrogance. The institution is burdened with substantial unpaid bills, and suppliers are not compensated in a timely manner; only those who consent to provide him with bribes and kickbacks receive payment. Furthermore, he employs intimidation, coercion, and threats against members of the Parents Association to endorse unlawful practices, such as unauthorized levies and additional school fees. Those who resist his directives face threats and retaliation. Board members are also subjected to intimidation, as he boasts of being untouchable due to his connections with influential politicians, including those at State House. He invokes prominent names from State House to deter anyone who seeks to hold him accountable for the misappropriated and lost funds.

Unconfirmed Payments for Tuition

lncluded as part of the tuition's payments are expenditures of Kshs.2,317,100 that relates to payments incurred in respect of laboratory equipment.

However, Management has not provided evidence of quotations from prequalified suppliers, details of delivery notes, stores ledgers and inspection committee reports confirming that the items procured were of the intended quality and quantity.

Unsupported Operations Expenses

Review of payment vouchers revealed that the School made payments amounting to Kshs.2,858,500 that relates to operations expenses to various suppliers on diverse dates during the period under review.

However, the audit revealed that the expenditures were not supported by quotations from the list of prequalified suppliers, local purchase orders indicating the items supplied, stores ledgers as evidence that the items were taken on charge in the store's ledgers and inspection committee report to confirm that the items supplied and services rendered were of the intended quality and quantity.

Further, the reported amount includes of Kshs.3,769,466 in respect of administration costs and Kshs.833,700 in respect of local transport expenses which has not been supported by workplan, evidence of travel from and back to work station nor explained.

Unconfirmed lnfrastructure Expenses

lncluded as part of the infrastructure's payments are expenditures of Kshs.1 ,442,000 that relates to payments incurred in respect of inter-account transfer - school fund. However, Management has not provided approval nor supplementary budget to transfer funds meant for other programs budgeted in school fund account to the infrastructure account.

ln the circumstances, the accuracy, completeness and propriety of the expenditure of Kshs.2,323,958 in respect to tuition expenses, Kshs.12,326,638 in respect of operation expenses and Kshs.2,900,845 in respect of infrastructure expenses could not be confirmed.

 

Unsupported Board of Management Sitting Allowance Rates

The statement of receipts and payments reflects an amount of Kshs.12,326,637 in respect of operations expenses which further includes an amount of Kshs.3,769,466 in respect of administration costs as disclosed in Note 7 to the financial statements.

Review of records revealed that Management made payments amounting to Kshs.313,000 in respect of academic committee meeting and two full board of managements meetings held on diverse dates during the period under review.

However, the board and committee meetings sitting allowances were not supported by attendance registers, invitation letters and agenda for the meetings. The members were paid allowances between Kshs.7,000 and Kshs.5,000, Management has not provided the any legal or other justification to support the rates of allowances being paid to the members.

Further, non-members of the board were also noted to have been paid sitting allowances which have not been explained.

ln the circumstances, the accuracy, completeness and propriety of the expenditure of Kshs.3,769,466 in respect of administration costs and regularity Kshs.313,000 in respect of board meetings could not be confirmed.

Unsupported Boarding and School Fund Payments Amount

The amount includes Kshs.5,171,844 paid to staff in cash, board of management teachers as motivation and local traders for supply of materials.

However, the supporting quotations from the list of prequalified suppliers, local purchase orders indicating the items to be supplied, stores ledgers as evidence that the items were taken on charge in the store's ledgers, and inspection and acceptance committee report confirming that the items supplied and services rendered were of the intended quality and quantity, were not provided for audit.

 

Unconfirmed Payments in Respect of Boarding and School Fund Payments

The balance of Kshs.22,548,153 also includes Kshs.532,500 and Kshs.86,400 in respect of inter-account borrowing - operations and school bus hire respectively which have not been supported with schedules, ledgers and cash book.

Approval from the board to incur expenditure from the vote-heads was not provided. ln the circumstances, the accuracy, completeness and propriety of the expenditure of Kshs.22,548,153 in respect of boarding and school fund payments and the value for money realized from the expenditure of Kshs.5,171,844 on the cash purchases could not be confirmed.Failure to lmplement an lmprest Management System

Review of the operations accounts, parents school fund account and infrastructure Account bank statements revealed that the Management made cash withdrawals amounting to Kshs.4,094,929 on diverse dates during the period under review.

However, the School does not issue imprest warrants or record in the imprest register cash advances made to various staff for carrying out School's activities.

Further, the audit revealed that the cash withdrawals were not supported by work-plan, evidence of work done or services rendered, cash sale receipts did not have electronic tax register generated receipts, quotations for competitive bidding not attached, items procured not taken on charge in the stores ledgers and deliveries made not inspected by the inspection and acceptance committee to ascertain the quality and quantity supplied.

This is contrary to the established government imprest procedures. ln the circumstances, Management is in breach of the law.

Non-Compliance with Law on Ethnic Diversity in Staffing

The statement of financial performance reflects total expenditure of Kshs.8,064,549 in respect of expenditure towards operations which includes personnel emoluments of Kshs.1 ,558,421as detailed in Note 7 to the financial statements.

Review of the payroll database for board of management teachers, non-teaching and subordinate staff revealed that the school has a total of fifty-two (52) employees, out of which thirty-one (31)which represent 60% comes from the same community contrary to Section 7(1) an (2) of the National Cohesion and lntegration Act, 2008 that requires all public establishments to seek to represent the diversity of the people of Kenya in employment of staff. ln the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Pressure Mounts on TSC as Parents, Stakeholders Seek Transfer of Wiobiero Principal Samuel Abuoro as Grade 10 students complain of sexual harassment

Stakeholders Reject Madam Ann Mwangangi as New Principal at Makueni Girls As Makueni Community Demands Local Principal Appointment

Millicent A. Ndiya disowns Ringa Girls audit report, blames predecessor Jane Murigi for corruption and financial mismanagement