Audit Report Highlights: Corruption and Mismanagement at Uhuru High School
Key Findings on Financial Irregularities and Governance Failures
- Unsubstantiated parental contributions and lack of invoicing systems
- Irregular recruitment and undocumented staff engagements
- Unsupported and overdue accounts payables and receivables
- Absence of an Executive Committee of Parent Association impacting governance
- Unauthorized fee charges breaching Ministry guidelines
- Delayed infrastructure grant transfers and misallocation of funds
- Excessive cash payments contrary to procurement regulations
- Stalled construction of academic block compromising school facilities
- Discrepancies between payment vouchers and cashbook records
- Unapproved board allowances and irregular sifting payments
Implications and Compliance Breaches
The audit reveals significant breaches of legal and financial regulations, exposing risks of fund misappropriation, loss of public resources, and compromised educational service delivery. Management and governance structures failed to ensure transparency, accountability, and adherence to statutory requirements.
Ngaruiya Thomas may be one of the leading principals summoned to appear before the parliamentary committee to address audit inquiries. The most recent report from the auditor general concerning Uhuru High School for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2025, has uncovered significant corruption, financial mismanagement, embezzlement of school funds, and procurement irregularities, including single-sourcing procurement methods, cash payments, and awarding contracts to companies that are neither pre-qualified nor registered with the school.
Under Ngaruiya's management, the school has reportedly lost millions of shillings due to fraudulent procurement practices, while the records of school fees have been manipulated to indicate that students owe substantial amounts in fee arrears. Additionally, suppliers are also owed money, with payments being made only to those willing to offer bribes and kickbacks.
THE AUDIT REPORT
Unsupported
School Fund lncome - Parents' Contributions
The
statement of financial performance reflects school fund income - parents' contributions
amount of Kshs.23,671,592 as disclosed in Note 4to the flnancial statements.
However,
the School did not have system generated invoices and receipts capturing
student details to support the revenue and ledgers.
Further,
the School did not provide the approved fee structure. ln addition, review of
records provided for audit revealed that bursaries received could not be traced
to the beneficiaries' student ledgers as amounts receipted lacked a narration
of whether they were in respect of bursary or other school fund income.
ln
addition, the School did not maintain a record of bursaries received from
National Government Constituency Development Fund (NG-CDF).
ln
the circumstances, the accuracy of the reported revenue from parents'
contribution amount of Kshs.23,671,592 could not be confirmed.
lrregular Recruitment of Board of Management Teachers and Non-Teaching Staffs
Review
of Human Resource records and payment vouchers revealed that the School engaged
non-teaching and Board of Management (BOM) teachers on a temporary basis to
address teacher shortages without formalizing employment procedures as the
following records were not provided;
Board
minutes supporting recruitment and approving the engagement of staffs. Signed
employment contracts or appointment letters.
Proof
of employment terms: salary, duration of employment and duties and
responsibilities. Personal files indicating the teacher qualifications and
Teachers Service Commission (TSC) registration numbers.
Payroll
records and payment details. Bank accounts used for salary payments; payments
are made in cash without acknowledgement signatures of recipients. Evidence of
remittance of statutory deductions.
ln
the circumstances, the efficiency in management of human resources operations
could not be confirmed.
Unsupported and Long Outstanding Accounts Payables
The
statement of assets and liabilities and as disclosed in Note 14 to the
financial statements reflects accounts payables balance of Kshs.11,378,937.
However,
the payables were not supported by invoices, trade payable movement schedule,
detailed aging analysis and payable ledgers.
Further,
included in the balance are accounts payables balance of Kshs.8,703,020 which
had been outstanding for more than two (2) years and did not form the first
charge during the year as required by Regulation 42(1)(a) of the Public Finance
Management (National Government) Regulations, 2015 which requires debt service
payments to form first charge during the year.
ln
the circumstances, the accuracy, existence and completeness of accounts
payables balance of Kshs.11,378,937 could not be confirmed and Management was
in breach of the law.
Unsupported and Long Outstanding Accounts Receivables
The
statement of assets and liabilities reflects accounts receivables balance of
Kshs.26,749,669 as disclosed in Note 13to the financial statements.
lncluded
in the balances are fees arrears amounting to Kshs.23,936,045 which has been
outstanding for more than one (1) year representing 89% of the total
receivables.
However,
there was no policy on the impairment of long outstanding fees arrears casting
doubt on full recoverability of the accounts receivables balance.
Further,
receivables which were more than one (1) year old totalling Kshs.23,936,045
were not supported with ledgers, detailed debtors aging analysis and system
generated invoices ln the circumstances, the accuracy and full recoverability
of the outstanding receivables balance of Kshs.26,749,669 could not be
confirmed.
Non-Establishment of Executive Committee of Parent Association
Review
of the composition of committees and the minutes for the committees revealed
that the School did not have an Executive Committee of Parents Association as
prescribed in Section 55 of the Basic Education Act,2013 (Third Schedule).
ln
the circumstances, the School did not achieve its strategic objectives and the
effectiveness of the governance mechanism at the School could not be confirmed.
Unsupported Payments
The
statement of financial performance reflects tuition, operations and
infrastructure expenses totalling Kshs.5,543,269 as disclosed in Note 6, Note 7
and Note 8 to the financial statements respectively.
However,
examination of payment vouchers amounting to Kshs.2,379,011 revealed that
Management made payments without proper support documents such as requisitions,
local purchase orders, delivery notes, inspection reports, goods received
notes, certificate of payments and requisite procurement documents.
ln
the circumstances, the regularity, accuracy and completeness of the reported
expenditure of Kshs.5,543,268 could not be confirmed
Late Submission of Financial Statements for Audit
During
the year under review, Management submitted the financial statements to the
Auditor-General on 24 February,2026 instead of the statutory deadline of 31
August, 2025 for 202412025 financial year.
This
was contrary to The National Treasury Circular No. AG.3/88 Vol.Vll(41) of 4
December, 2024 in compliance which Section 81 of the Public Finance Management
Act,2012 on preparation of the financial statements. ln the circumstances,
Management was in breach of the law
Unapproved Fees Payment under School Fund lncome - Parents Contribution
The
statement of financial performance reflects school fund income - parents'
contributions amount of Kshs.23,671,592 as disclosed in Note 4 to the financial
statements.
Examination
of fee payment records revealed that the School charged an amount of
Kshs.10,000 per student to support the fund.
The
School however, did not obtain authorization from the Ministry of Education to
charge the extra fees in the year under review as required in the guidelines on
implementation of Free Day and Secondary Education Programme.
ln
the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law
Late Transfers of lnfrastructure Grants
The
statement of financial performance reflects revenue totalling Kshs.28,469,420
which include Government grants for infrastructure amount of Kshs.1,125,500.
However, it was noted that the School transferred Kshs.1 ,125,500 from
operations account to infrastructure accounts after lapse of 15 days from the
date of receipts.
This
was contrary to the Ministry guidelines that requires infrastructure grants be
transferred to the infrastructure account from operation account within 15 days
from the date of disbursement. ln the circumstances, Management was in breach
of the guidelines.
lrregular Misallocation of Funds
Audit
review of bank statements and payment vouchers revealed that, an amount of
Ksh.483,000 was transferred from the school infrastructure account to the
school fund account. However, the misallocation was not approved by the Board
of Management and no reason was provided for diverting the funds.
ln
the circumstances, the propriety and regularity of the transfer of Kshs.483,000
could not be confirmed and the diversion of funds may lead to misuse of funds
earmarked for infrastructure development.
Non-Compliance with Requirements for Standing lmprest
The
statement of financial performance reflects boarding and school fund payments
of Kshs.24,591 ,718 as disclosed in Note 9 to the financial statements.
Review
of boarding and school fund payments revealed that the School incurred an
amount totalling Kshs.3,161,605 through payments in cash.
However,
the School did not provide approval for the establishment of the imprest or
cash facility from the Accounting Officer or AIE holder or the Board of
Management including the maximum amount for the specific purpose of that
facility and purposes.
The
cash payments were not supported by a memorandum cash book recording all
receipts and payments from the cash withdrawals.
Further,
it was noted that the School procured goods and services using cash purchase
contrary to Regulation 92(a) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal
Regulations, 2020 which provide the estimated cost of the goods, works or
services being procured per item per financial year is as per the threshold
matrix in the Second Schedule.
ln
addition, it was noted that the suppliers issued non-vatable cash sale receipts
to the School, thereby denying the Government revenue from VAT and capacity
building levy.
ln
the circumstances, the regularity, maximum amount of withdrawal and purpose of
the cash withdrawals could not be confirmed.
Long Outstanding Accounts Payables
The
statement of assets and liabilities and as disclosed in Note 14 to the
financial statements reflects accounts payables balance of Kshs.11,378,937.
However,
included in the balance are trade creditors balance of Kshs.8,703,020 that has
been outstanding for more than two (2) years and did not form the first charge
during the year as required by Regulation 42(1)(a) of the Public Finance
Management (National Government) Regulations, 2015 which requires debt service
payments to form first charge during the year. ln the circumstances, the School
Management was in breach of the law and there is risk loss of public funds
through litigations, interests and penalties.
lrregular Payment of Sifting Allowance
The
statement of financial performance reflects operations payments amount of
Kshs.3,653,978 as disclosed in Note 7 to the financial statements, which
includes Board allowances of Kshs.440,780.
However,
review of payment records revealed that the Chairperson and Members of the
Board were paid Kshs.6,000 and Kshs.3,000 respectively per sitting, however,
Board minutes and approval from the Cabinet Secretary approving payment of the
allowances were not provided for audit review hence the basis for payment of
the allowances could therefore not be confirmed.
ln
the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of the board allowance could
not be confirmed.
Excessive Use
of Cash to Procure Goods, Works and Services
The
statement of financial performance reflects total expenditure amount of
Kshs.30,134,986. Audit review of the cash book and payment vouchers revealed
that the School used cash totalling Kshs.3,564,275 to purchase goods, services
and works instead of procuring using other suitable methods. This was contrary
to the procedure for low value procurement.
ln
the circumstances, the School may not have received value for money for the
expenditure totalling Kshs.3,564,275.
lrregular Procurement of Boarding and School Fund ltems
The statement of financial performance reflects boarding and school fund expenditure totalling Kshs.24,591,718 as disclosed in Note 9 to the financial statements.
However,
examination of payment vouchers provided for audit review revealed that the
School procured goods, services and works amounting to Kshs.9,521,403 from
suppliers who were not evaluated in an open tender for the financial year
202412025.
The
School therefore directly sourced goods, services and works from supplier
without following the procurement process.
This
was contrary to Article 227 of the Constitution of Kenya that states that
procurement should be fair, equitable, transparent, competitive and
costeffective. ln the circumstances, the School was in breach of the law.
Stalled Construction of Academic Block
The
audit revealed that the School commenced the construction of an academic block
valued at Kshs.17,794,950 in the year 2017. Physical verification of the
project revealed that the project had stalled and remained abandoned as at, 30
June, 2025.
Stalled
projects are an indication that the public has been denied benefits that would
have accrued from the completed projects and that value for money invested in
the projects has not been realized. Further, physical verification of the
academic block revealed the block has remained unfinished for more than five
(5) years with the second and third floor incomplete and the building lacking
ramp for use by persons with disabilities.
ln
addition, the uncompleted floors were observed to be in use by the students as
classrooms.
Variance between Payment Vouchers and the Cashbook
The
statement of financial performance reflects operations expenditure amount of
Kshs.3,653,978 as disclosed in Note 7 to the financial statements. However,
examination of payment vouchers revealed that the payment vouchers and invoices
amounting to Kshs.384,520 differed with amount accounted for in the cashbook of
Kshs.653,105 resulting to overpayment and unsupported expenditure of
Kshs.268,585.
ln
the circumstances, the accuracy of the reported expenditure of Kshs.3,653,978
could not be confirmed.

Comments
Post a Comment