Controversy and Crisis at Moi Girls hIGHSchool, Kamusinga: Financial Mismanagement and Audit Irregularities Exposed




HIGHLIGHTS

Calls for Leadership Change Amidst Declining Discipline and Academic Performance

Allegations of Sexual Misconduct and Administrative Negligence

Unpaid Bills, Corruption, and Abuse of Power in School Management

Community Demands Accountability and a Principal from the Local Region

Ethnic Imbalance and Legal Breaches in School Staffing

Failure to Adhere to Procurement Laws Fuels Governance Concerns

Academic Results Under Scrutiny: Stakeholders Demand Reform

All does not appear to be well at Moi Girls Senior School, Kamusinga, as stakeholders raise significant concerns regarding the management of the institution. The individual at the center of the controversy is the school’s administration, led by Chief Principal Joyce Mulunda.

Serious audit queries have been reported, with the principal being prominently mentioned in a public audit report released by transparency organizations and the Auditor General. She faces allegations of financial mismanagement related to irregular fund transfers. An audit report from the Elimu Bora Working Group, which references findings from national financial reviews, has flagged Moi Girls' Kamusinga for conducting irregular cash transfers. The routing of over KSh 1.7 million in public funds to the Kenya Secondary School Heads Association (KESSHA), which falls outside standard regulatory practices, is currently under investigation. The school has come under scrutiny for unsupported expenditures, missing records, and non-compliance with established procurement and financial reporting standards. Sources from a member of the Parents Association have indicated that there is pressure on the Teachers Service Commission to transfer Madam Mulunda, as she has not succeeded in advancing the school’s academic and infrastructural development. Stakeholders, parents, and the local community have largely concurred that it is time for Madam Mulunda to resign, allowing for the appointment of a principal from Bungoma County, referred to as the "daughter of the soil." It has been reported that the level of discipline has declined since Madam Mulunda assumed her position. Incidents of same-sex relationships have reportedly increased. Grade ten students are alleged to have been sexually molested and harassed by senior girls, with cases of same-sex relationships becoming widespread. Despite students reporting instances of sexual harassment to the principal, it is claimed that she has entirely failed to take action to protect the young girls from such immoral behavior.

The students have developed a belief that she either covertly endorses the immoral actions of the LGBTQ group or possibly is a member of this illegal organization, which may be the reason for the ongoing suffering of the young girls, thus prompting calls for her immediate transfer. Additionally, it has been reported that the school is burdened with significant unpaid bills due to ineffective management policies. Suppliers remain unpaid despite having received approvals from the Board of Management (BoM). Allegations suggest that she only compensates suppliers who are willing to offer bribes and kickbacks. Advocates for her transfer assert that she administers the school with an iron fist, employing intimidation, coercion, and arrogance. She pressures members of the Parents Association (PA) to endorse illegal activities such as excessive levies. Those within the Parents Association who express differing views are threatened and coerced into approving these unlawful actions. The academic performance of the school is underwhelming. It is important to highlight that while she boasts of a positive shift in the last KCSE results, Madam Mulunda must clarify to parents why 12 students received a C MINUS (C-), 68 students earned a D PLUS (D+), 162 students achieved a D PLAIN, and 112 students were awarded a D MINUS. Stakeholders are now stating that these results are unacceptable, and unless she introduces new academic programs, she will not be permitted to reopen the school next year.

THE ROT, FINANCIAL MISMAGEMENT AS EXPOSED BY THE AUDITOR GENERAL

UNCONFIRMED SCHOOL FUND LNCOME - PARENTS' CONTRIBUTIONS

The statement of receipts and payments indicates school fund income-parents contributions amounting to Kshs.103,190,496, and as disclosed in Note 4 to the financial statements. However, the supporting schedules totals to Kshs.98,695,590, resulting in an unreconciled variance of Kshs.4,494,906.

ln the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of school fund income-parents contributions amounting to Kshs.103,190,496 could not be confirmed.

 

UNCONFIRMED PAYMENTS FOR BOARDING AND SCHOOL FUND

The statement of receipts and payments indicates payments for boarding and schoolfund amounting to Kshs.94,310,213, and as disclosed in Note 9 to the financial statements. However, the supporting schedules totals to Kshs.107,546,902, resulting in an unreconciled variance of Kshs.1 3,236,689. ln the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of boarding and School fund amounting to Kshs.94,310,213 could not be confirmed.

UNCONFIRMED ACCOUNTS PAYABLES BALANCE

The statement of assets and liabilities reflect accounts payables balance of Kshs.14,131,704and as disclosed in Note 14 to the financial statements, which comprises trade creditors of Kshs.2,181,549 and prepaid fees amounting to Kshs.11,950,155.

However, the prepaid fees were not supported by a list of pre-paid students. Further, Annex 1 to the financial statements in respect to analysis of pending accounts payable reflects trade creditors amounting to Kshs.1,813,098, resulting in an unexplained variance of Kshs.368,451.

ln the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of accounts payables balance of Kshs.14,131,704 could not be confirmed.

LRREGULAR PAYMENTS TO KENYA SECONDARY SCHOOLS HEADS ASSOCIATION

During the year under review, the School paid an amount of Kshs.463,000 to Kenya Secondary School Heads Association (KESSHA). However, KESSHA is a welfare organization that draws its membership from school principals only.

The organization was not defined in government funding system and there was no assurance that it had implemented effective, efficient, and transparent financial management and internal control systems to manage the funds transferred by Schools.

ln the circumstances, value for money transferred to KESSHA amounting to Kshs.463,000 could not be confirmed.

LACK OF DIVERSITY IN STAFF ETHNICITY

Review of staff bio data reviewed that thirty-two (32) out of thirty-four (34) or 94% of the non-teaching and support staff belonged to one ethnic group. This was contrary to Section 7(1) and (2) of the National Cohesion and lntegration Act, 2008 which states that all public offices shall seek to represent the diversity of the people of Kenya in employment of staff and that no public institution shall have more than one third of its staff establishment from the same ethnic community. Further, the School did not reserve 5% staff positions for people living with disabilities as required by the law. ln the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law

LACK OF AN ANNUAL! PROCUREMENT PLAN

During the year under review, the Management did not prepare an annual procurement plan as part of the annual budget preparation process. This was contrary to Regulation 40(1) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Regulations, 2020 which states that a procuring entity shall prepare a procurement plan for each financial year as part of the annual budget preparation process. ln the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.

FAILURE TO DEDUCT PUBLIC PROCUREMENT CAPACITY BUILDING LEVY

Review of the procurement records indicates that the School signed procurement contracts amounting to Kshs.70,894,398 with suppliers.

However, review of the payments vouchers for goods and services contracts revealed that there was no deduction of the public procurement capacity building levy of 0.03% on the contracts, contrary to the Levy Order 2023 issued by the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority.

 

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Pressure Mounts on TSC as Parents, Stakeholders Seek Transfer of Wiobiero Principal Samuel Abuoro as Grade 10 students complain of sexual harassment

Stakeholders Reject Madam Ann Mwangangi as New Principal at Makueni Girls As Makueni Community Demands Local Principal Appointment

Millicent A. Ndiya disowns Ringa Girls audit report, blames predecessor Jane Murigi for corruption and financial mismanagement